< Back to front page Text size +

More on tie-breakers

Posted by Ricky Popolizio, Globe Correspondent  November 21, 2007 06:55 AM
  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

E-mail this article

Invalid email address
Invalid email address

Sending your article

Your article has been sent.

(Following up with more on tie-breakers. You can check out this article in today's Globe detailing the potential for tie-breakers in the Dual County and Atlantic Coast Leagues):

Marshfield football coach Lou Silva is weary of point-differential systems.

"Any time you have any point differential, it could lead to something that's unhealthy," said Silva.

Westford coach Mike Parent, meanwhile, is wary of a "last-to-go" tie-breaker.

"Say you had a team that went [to the playoffs] five years ago and another that went 30 years ago. The team that went five years ago would be blocked out and we didn't think that was fair because the kids five years ago would all be removed from the program. Why penalize the next group that comes in? They were probably in the 5th or 6th grade when they watched a championship and just because that team was successful, they can't play in a Super Bowl?"

All the coaches polled agreed that, under this system, teams that were one or two years removed from an appearance could be penalized because the kids had already experienced the playoffs.

When Westford and Acton square off in their annual Thanksgiving festival, both coaches implied they would stick to their guns and do everything in their power to come away with a win.

"It's more important to win than score a lot of points," said Acton-Boxboro coach Bill Maver, noting that both are quite important to his team this year. "We are playing a good team. We're not going into the game thinking we have to score 24 points or more. We want our kids to go out on a good note. At the worst, if we win, we were tri-champs and got a piece of the title. I don't think our chances of getting into the playoffs are very good, but we'll do the best we can. That's all we can do."

Added Parent: "I wouldn't be surprised if Acton doesn't do anything differently because you want to stay within your character, but I'm sure if they got close to those points, that's going to be something they'll shoot for. He'd be crazy if he didn't."

There were two common beliefs among the coaches regarding Turkey Day and the tie-breakers. First and foremost, the objective on Thanksgiving is to win. As for the tie-breaking method of the future, it was a landslide. The coin toss is not an option. The last-to-go can work, but often doesn't. The best option appears to be a tweaked point-differential system, which would only compare the scores in the head-to-head games of those affected teams at the end of the season. A cap to the point differential could also be instituted, as well, at around 20 or 21 points, similar to the Middlesex League's current format.

"Then you aren't trying to run up the score on the teams that aren't in the mix," said Wayland coach Scott Parseghian. "That's the focus in the next league meeting."

Parent added, "I'm sure this will be a hot topic because it creates a lot of controversy. And it sells newspapers."

At the end of the day, it's all about chance, and each coach subconsciously used their own cliché.

"I think most people feel the chips will fall wherever they fall," said Parent.

"We'll either be collecting equipment on Thursday afternoon or we won't be," said Lincoln-Sudbury coach Tom Lopez.

"That's just a gentleman's agreement and, whether right or wrong, that's the way it goes," said Plymouth North coach Bill Burkhead.

"This is what we came up with and, to quote a famous coach, 'It is what it is,'" said Maver. "We hope the turkey tastes good, No. 1, and we'll go from there. If we're not fortunate enough to win on Thanksgiving Day, we'll look back and say we could've taken care of business earlier and we didn't."

  • E-mail
  • E-mail this article

    Invalid E-mail address
    Invalid E-mail address

    Sending your article

    Your article has been sent.

Several reporters and editors contribute updates, news and analysis to the High School Sports Blog.

  • Bob Holmes: A Reading resident (Go Rockets!) and Boston College graduate, Holmes is the Boston Globe High School Sports Editor. We remind you now that his weekly picks are often made in jest so everyone just calm down when he picks against Everett for 11 straight weeks. Contact him at rholmes@globe.com. Follow him on Twitter @GlobeHolmes.
  • Craig Larson: A native of West Springfield (Leo Durocher anyone? Tim Daggett?) and Curry College graduate (a proud Colonel!), Larson is the sports editor for the Globe's regional sections: South, West and North, as well as a frequent contributor on the college beat. Abington to Xaverian: it all starts with the schools. Have a compelling story idea? Contact him at clarson@globe.com. Follow him on Twitter @GlobeLars.
  • Zuri Berry: Berry attended the same high school as sports legends O.J. Simpson and Joe DiMaggio. (Guess which one is his hero.) He's a South Boston resident (formerly of Eastie) and the editor of the High School Sports blog as well as the go-to-guy for everything high school sports on Boston.com. Contact him at zberry@boston.com and follow him on Twitter @ZuriBerry for all of the latest updates.

Also expect updates from correspondents Seth Lakso (boys basketball), Hannah Becker (girls basketball), Craig Forde (boys hockey), Liz Torres (girls hockey), Ryan Mooney and a host of others. To reach the high school sports correspondents and Globe editors, e-mail hssports@globe.com.


H.S. Sports Twitter

    Waiting for Twitter...
archives