< Back to front page
Text size
–
+
Forsberg 5 (Thanksgiving edition)
Here's your cheat-sheet for the Beat Forsberg: Thanksgiving Pick'em 2008 contest. Below you'll find the usual Forsberg 5, with our quick analysis on all 30 games in this year's contest.
For a quick glance at my picks, check out this ballot from the VIP section of our pick 'em contest.
Without further ado, here's this year's Thanksgiving Day picks (home teams in caps):
- BC HIGH (8-1) over Catholic Memorial (8-1) -- BC High saves everyone from busting out their abacuses by winning the Catholic Conference title outright. We don't want to belabor the point about schedules, but the Knights simply didn't challenge themselves sufficiently to be competitive in these final weeks of the season. It's too bad because there's plenty of talent on this team. It's simply hard to kick it to another gear when you run into the Xaverians and BC Highs of the world to close out the season.
- Natick (9-1) over FRAMINGHAM (8-2) -- We're concerned about the health of Natick quarterback Scott McCummings (who couldn't finish the Herget battle against Walpole), but we also think the Flyers might be inclined to ensure their own health with a trip to the postseason looming five days after Thanksgiving. That's not to say the Flyers don't want to win this game, but this amounts to the Red and Blue's Super Bowl and Tom Lamb's charges probably wouldn't mind making a statement about how good the Herget was this fall.
- Duxbury (10-0) over MARSHFIELD (9-1) -- We think Duxbury simply has more motivation to take this game for two reasons: 1) A perfect 11-0 season is accomplished with a win and 2) The Dragons haven't exactly been challenged since Week 2 of the season (the Silver Lake game a possible exception). The Division 2A playoffs are loaded with talent and Duxbury really needs to kick it back into high gear, so why not start here. All that said, the Rams wouldn't mind finishing the season 10-1 and getting a quality win before the Division 1A playoffs.
- APPONEQUET (10-0) over Old Rochester (7-3) -- We're not saying it's intentional, but there sure seems to be the perfect amount of room next to the helmet graphic to add "2008" to the list of South Coast Conference championships on the Lakers website. Of course, it'll be sweeter to add that year as an outright championship capping a perfect season.
- North Attleboro (7-2) over ATTLEBORO (8-2) -- We'll crown this the best game involving two teams not heading to the playoffs (a backhanded compliment that also featured St. John's Prep vs. Xaverian, Melrose vs. Wakefield, and Billerica vs. Chelmsford among the finalists for the award). North Attleboro caps a very respectable fall in which its only losses came against playoff-bound teams (Bishop Feehan and Mansfield).
And this week's laundry list of quick picks sure to destroy my glistening season record:
- Walpole (10-0) over WEYMOUTH (4-6) -- Ignore the Wildcats' recent struggles, this one will still be a brawl, but Walpole prevails.
- South Boston (9-1) over EAST BOSTON (5-4) -- South Boston is evidently postseason bound regardless of the outcome . . . that doesn't mean they won't take care of business on Turkey Day.
- Newburyport (5-5) over AMESBURY (9-1) -- Can't fathom that this game means more to anyone than Joe Clancy, who atones for last year's absence by adding at least one more game to the Clippers' 2008 schedule.
- XAVERIAN (6-4) over St. John's Prep (5-5) -- We're not one to throw out idle threats, but as impressive as Xaverian has been in 2008, the Hawks (probably) won't be in our final Top 20 with five losses.
- LINCOLN-SUDBURY (8-2) over Newton South (4-6) -- Without having to worry about the out-of-town scoreboard, Lincoln-Sudbury's focus is on the field.
- Everett (8-1) over CAMBRIDGE (4-5) -- Not the same without a playoff berth at stake, but the folks in Malden wouldn't mind a share of the Greater Boston League crown if the Falcons could pull off an upset.
- KING PHILIP (8-2) over Franklin (7-3) -- The Warriors are last year's Panthers.
- Holbrook (6-2) over WEST BRIDGEWATER (5-4) -- Previous results don't guarantee future success, but we can't imagine too much has changed since Oct. 11.
- CHELMSFORD (6-4) over Billerica (7-3) -- We'll take experience over youth here and hope that Billerica can shake off the sting of losing four of its last five to rebound in 2009.
- Melrose (8-1) over WAKEFIELD (7-1) -- All right, we admit it, we simply picked the team that played Reading more competitively.
- SWAMPSCOTT (8-2) over Marblehead (6-4) -- We're still trying to wrap our heads around Marblehead's lopsided loss to Saugus. Maybe the Big Blue should think about focusing on their ground game after the Magicians were torched for 460 yards in that 41-13 loss in Week 11.
- MEDWAY (9-1) over Millis (5-5) -- No reason to believe Medway won't rebound from a loss to Norton in Week 11, but kudos to Millis on a spectacular season after its struggles the past two falls.
- BOSTON LATIN (0-10) over Boston English (3-7) -- Pop quiz: When was the last time this game was decided by fewer than two touchdowns? Answer: My junior year in high school (English won, 8-6, in 1997). The question without an answer: When will the game be competitive again?
- Brockton (7-3) over WALTHAM (3-7) -- This rather unorthodox rivalry (nonleague rivals situated 30 miles apart) continues to thrive, just like the Boxers late in the 2008 season.
- POPE JOHN (6-4) over Lowell Catholic (7-3) -- As we usually do in these situations, we defer to nonleague schedules and we really like how Pope John has challenged itself.
- Bishop Feehan (8-1) over SANDWICH (6-4) -- Mmmmm . . . hot turkey sandwiches. Wait, what were we talking about? Football?
- ACTON-BOXBORO (9-1) over Westford Academy (7-3) -- The wheels have come off a bit for Westford Academy after a fast start, but it would have been an uphill battle versus the Colonials regardless of the Ghosts's record.
- ARLINGTON (6-4) over Arlington Catholic (7-3) -- This first crosstown meeting should be a doozy with both teams playing inspired ball (and both winning conference crowns this fall; though Belmont can still force a tie atop the Dual County League Small). But this is Arlington's postseason, so we'll give the edge to the Spy Ponders.
- TAUNTON (5-5) over Coyle-Cassidy (7-3) -- Taunton played four Top 20 squads this fall and matchups with juggernauts like BC High and Dartmouth help you win games like this.
- MANSFIELD (9-1) over Foxboro (3-7) -- It's a down year for Foxboro, but Mansfield won't be taking it easy on its rival.
- Tewksbury (2-8) over WILMINGTON (9-1) -- Toss aside the records. If Tewksbury can topple a team like Chelmsford, they should be able to bring home a 'W' against Wilmington.
- LYNN ENGLISH (6-3) over Lynn Classical (5-4) -- English proved to be just a little bit more competitive in its losses than Classical was against similar teams.
- Georgetown (8-1) over MANCHESTER-ESSEX (10-0) -- With 18 combined wins for these two teams, it should be one of the better Turkey Day matchups.
- NEEDHAM (5-5) over Wellesley (2-8) -- Neither team comes roaring into this one (Wellesley with five straight losses; Needham with three), but we like the Rockets to close out the year on a high note and secure a winning campaign.
- Fitchburg (6-4) over LEOMINSTER (6-4) -- Buoyed by its recent triumph over Wachusett, the Red Raiders simply want it more than the Blue Devils want to play spoiler.
Last week: 8-5
Year to date: 95-29 (.766)



What about Marlborough vs. Hudson?
Forsberg's response:
Marlborough hosts Hudson this year. Wait, again not what you were looking for?
What about Dartmouth v. Fairhaven ?
I have gone to 48 English-Latin games in a row. For a number of reasons I will miss this year's game. Whether this game can ever be competitive again is dubious. Thirty thousand cheering fans at Harvard Stadium made this game one of the "nice" things about Boston. But sometimes the past is the past. (Hope I am wrong.)
I feel as if CM can overtake BC High.You're taking into account BC's history of excellency. But its a new year. CM was leading in PPG and PA until the Xaverian game.. They made many of their opponents look silly. I will admit that losing to Xaverian was a big set back but CM's running game is going to pound BC High's D-Line into the ground.
The Amesbury High Seniors have had Newburyport's number all 3 years. As Freshman this team went undefeated and they have many stars...they play as a team! The game is being played in the best high school stadium around, James J. Landry Jr Memorial Stadium and this team will protect their home turf!
What about Tantasqua vs. Shepard Hill?
Forsberg's response:
We're all for Central Mass. games, but let's not get crazy.
How about the Newton North and Winthrop games?
North Reading (4-6) over Lynnfield (2-8) The Hornets Rizzo/Hartwell 1-2 punch too much for the Pioneers to handle.
Who do you think will win the Braintree vs. Milton game?
Latin will prevail over English in the longest running rivalry, but only in spite of its useless coach. BLS administrators, please give the kids a coach who actually can, and cares to, win!
What about Gloucester v. Danvers....Rather important as Gloucester won the Super Bowl last year 47 to 0 and is 9 and 1 and headed to the Super Bowl this year....
Forsberg's response:
The Fish are headed to the playoffs, but let's not punch that Super Bowl pass quite yet. And I don't think pitting a 9-1 team against a 1-9 team would be much of a challenge for our pigskin pickers.
What about Ipswich vs Hamilton-Wenham?
Forsberg's response:
Bit of a rough season for Ipswich.
What about Woburn v. Winchester?
CM's schedule was a JOKE this year. they didn't challenge themselves at all outside of the conference. Plymouth South between Catholic Conference games? seriously? No insult to South, but CM could have sent out the JV team and still won that game. PPG and PA mean absolutely nothing when you play the likes of Boston Latin and Lynn Classical when Xaverian and BC High are playing Everett and Brockton. I hope CM beats BCH, but i just dont see it. BCH has too much at stake. I'd be shocked if they come up short.
Woburn vs Winchester? Come on Chris, this is the Superbowl bout of the year!!
Without Dan Eramian in the stands, there goes EHS chances this year! (Hi Dan)
What about Cardinal Spellman H.S?
By the way...............GO CM!!! (I know they'll pull it out! They were fine up until Xaverian.......they'll be even finer after BC!!!)
Forsberg's response:
It's been a long time since either Spellman or Archbishop Williams tasted victory. We'll give a slight edge to the Cardinals, who have been a little better defensively.
HI Barry...you cheer for me this year .
I don't know why people trash on BC High so much, they run a good honest program...I have seen it from the inside for a few years now. There is absolutely no comparing CM's schedule to BC High's for this past season. BC's coach being new to the program went out to prove something with his schedule picks, CM didn't prove much with theirs. BC High wins at home, no question...they want Everett in a BIG way.
GO TAUNTON TIGERS - BEAT COYLE!!!
BCH in a walk over CM, which hurts to say as an X fan. Horan will score at least twice. CM just has not played the right teams to be competitive with BC.
What about Woburn vs. Winchester?
Forsberg's response:
We flipped a coin 10 times and each team won five times.
what about revere and winthrop? this has been a very good rival over the last 20 years.
Forsberg's response:
Without much research, we'll take Winthrop.
Once again, Newton North will trounce those pesky Brookline wimps. And we will smile.
Go Latin! Bomb the Blue!
Winchester wins in runaway and shocks the Middlesex world!
I can not for the life of me understand why you would pick Newburyport over Amesbury.Someone has not done their homework!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
you would think the #1, undefeated and top team in the state Dartmouth would get a little mention here...
How about Pope John HS? The little team from Everett has won five straight, outscoring their opponents 169-28 in that stretch, after starting 1-4. If the Tigers can beat Lowell Catholic today they move on to the postseason.
What about the Cell-ah Bowl, OA vs Sharon? Both fighting to get in the W column @ Stonehill.
scituate hingham
Stoughton should no doubt beat Canton. They did it last year and they'll do it again.
I live in Cheywnne whyoming and it must be after 3;00 P.M THERE AND THERE IS NO SCORE ON THE qUINCY NORTH QUINCY GAME. i HAVE A DOLLAR BIT AND NEED TO KNOW THE SCORE,
Forsberg, you gave no love to the West bridgewater team, but you didnt realize the game we lost to Holbrook 22-6 was a complete fluke. The Wildcats were 6-0 against Holbrook on Thanksgiving, you should've looked at that statistic instead of the score. Now I'm full from all the delicious turkey, while the Bulldogs have to wait another year to try and beat West Bridgewater. Man does it feel good.
This blogger might want to review your comment before posting it.
Look for updates from:
H.S. Sports Twitter
Waiting for Twitter...
stay in touch
E-mail your question to Boston.com's Chris Forsbergbrowse this blog
by categoryINside Boston.com