Mediocre bad guys
In the end, the disappointing truth is this: It was the New England Patriots' own fault and no one else's that they didn't get an invitation to the postseason party. As Richard Seymour said during this afternoon's player postmortems at Gillette Stadium, the Patriots lost to the Colts, Steelers, and Chargers, so what do they really have to complain about?
To put it another way: When you have to count on Brett Favre rescuing your season, the cause is already lost. (Somewhere, Eric Mangini nods solemnly while engulfing his third $5 Footlong of this day and wondering if he can get away with sneaking Bill Belichick onto his list of references.)
The Patriots simply let too many opportunities slip through their hands along the way -- literally, in Jabar Gaffney's case during the ultimately costly loss to the Colts -- and those calling for a change in the playoff system today are simply doing so out of frustration and parochialism. The Patriots are the first 11-win team to miss the postseason since current 12-team playoff format was implemented in 1990, which tells you that in the vast majority of seasons, the system works flawlessly.
But even as we sit here wishing that the season could have lasted a few weekends longer -- and I know I'm not the only one who thought the battered but peaking Patriots had a chance to make some noise in the playoffs, particularly had the Jets won and Ravens lost yesterday -- I think this is a team that leaves us with warm memories to get through the winter. Given how it all began -- with the franchise quarterback crumpled on the turf and our hopes apparently snuffed out barely seven minutes into the season -- that is a truly remarkable thing.
In many ways, I enjoyed this season more than last, when the Patriots ran roughshod over the rest of the NFL while being cast as villains (and worse) from coast to coast, only to be left stunned as their detractors gloated and celebrated that "1" in the loss column at the end.
We've been trained during the franchise's unprecedented success to believe that a season was only successful if it ended with a Super Bowl victory, and that mind-set makes sense to some extent; it sounds smug, but you hate to see that window of opportunity close without all of your championship hopes being fulfilled.
But given what the Patriots endured in terms of injuries this season -- and that's not an excuse, it's the reality -- only the most demanding among us would consider this season anything less than a success.
The 2008 Patriots weren't champions, but they sure were admirable. I'm going to miss watching them.
* * *
I'll remain forever convinced that no other coach in the NFL could have coaxed 11 victories out of this team after the devastating developments of Week 1, and what Belichick accomplished with this season's tattered roster should restore all of the luster to his reputation that he supposedly lost during last season's ESPN-endorsed soap opera.
But anyone who suggests that he pulled off his greatest coaching job this season has an extremely short memory. I've probably written this a half-dozen times this season, but I'll say it again: Beating the Rams and winning the Super Bowl XXXVI with a patchwork roster ranks among the single greatest coaching feats in NFL history -- and it may be at the very top of the list.
* * *
I leave the worst-case scenarios to others, and keep it simple: I enjoyed the hell out of watching Matt Cassel play this season -- he just kept getting better and better and better, until it got to the point that he was pretty much the least of the team's worries -- and beyond that, he seems like a genuinely decent and grounded person.
I hope he's someone else's starting quarterback next season -- every Patriots fan in possession of a clue hopes that Tom Brady returns to good health and good form -- but if Cassel's stint as the Patriots' starter is to end at 15 games, he's created an impressive and lasting legacy for himself in such a brief time. I couldn't be more impressed.
* * *
Peter King's eternal man-crush on Brett Favre has long since rocketed past the point of amusement and now falls somewhere between creepy and annoying -- how predictable was it that he didn't list the chief perpetrator of the Jets' downfall among his "Goats of the Week" in today's column?
But it's more than just his unwillingness or ability to recognize Favre's flaws -- his blindness is such that he actually wrote this the week Tom Brady got hurt:
But my very, very strong opinion is that had Favre stayed retired, and if Brady got hurt, and if the Patriots came calling (which they most certainly would have), Favre would be in Foxboro today.
"Most certainly would have"? In retrospect, the thought is preposterous, but it was also a silly notion then -- yes, the Patriots supposedly needed a quarterback, but King should have recognized that Favre owns every single one of the attributes Belichick loathed in Drew Bledsoe . . . something he almost stumbled upon later in the column:
The Patriots had grown tired of Bledsoe in 2001, thinking he was too much of a signal-calling maverick rather than going with the flow of what the team had game-planned for all week.
A maverick. Much worse than a gunslinger, apparently. Sheesh.
* * *
I hopped aboard the LaMont Jordan train as soon as the Patriots signed him, and while he wasn't as durable as the Patriots would have hoped, he added an extremely valuable element of a running game that was quietly one of the NFL's best.
I hope they find a way to bring him back next season. These last few weeks, he's reinforced my belief that he's a running back who can help a team accomplish meaningful things in December and January.
* * *
Although they were generally little more than cardboard cutouts of their former selves in terms of production, I thoroughly enjoyed seeing old friends Junior Seau and Rosevelt Colvin do their best to help salvage the Patriots' battered linebacking corps these past few weeks.
Seau and Colvin may have had their greatest individual highlights elsewhere, but I'll remember both of them as the epitome of what we want a Patriot player to be. Beyond that, I think it speaks volumes about Belichick's perception among players that he essentially has a taxi squad of respected semi-retired veterans to call upon at a moment's notice.
* * *
I like the idea of karma, but I guess I've always been skeptical of the notion; good things too often happen to lousy people without repercussions, you know? But yesterday at the Meadowlands . . . well, karma made a hell of a case for its existence.
You had Brett Favre, one of the most overrated, self-aggrandizing, media-savvy athletes of his time, coughing up yet another hairball in a big moment.
You had Chad Pennington, who is everything Favre isn't, efficiently sticking it to the team that casually dismissed him in favor of the washed-up Wranglers Warrior -- and at their place, no less.
And you had Eric Mangini, the NFL's King Rat, finally getting his comeuppance as the team's decision-makers realized that his (since severed) connection to Belichick didn't mean he was Belichick.
For a Patriots fan, there had to be at least a small measure of satisfaction in all of that.
* * *
Oh, and while we're at it, almost forgot:
With the No. 6 selection in the 2008 NFL Draft, the New York Jets select Vernon Gholston, linebacker, Ohio State. Final rookie numbers: 15 games, 13 tackles.
With the No. 10 selection in the 2008 NFL Draft, the New England Patriots select Jerod Mayo, linebacker, Tennessee. Final rookie numbers: 16 games, 128 tackles.
No, I don't really believe in schadenfreude, either. Why do you ask?
* * *
I have a hard time pinning "blame" on anyone for the way the Patriots season played out -- again, it was a remarkably fulfilling and enjoyable year in pretty much every way other than the final outcome -- but if there's a chance of bringing Romeo Crennel back at the expense of Dean Pees and/or Dom Capers, let's just say I'm all in favor of getting the ol' band back together again, even if it means Belichick has to be extra ruthless to make it happen. (The "ol' band," of course, excludes Mangini.)
* * *
As for today's Completely Random Baseball Card:
I don't think I've ever made it through a Pats column without a Sox reference, so why start now? Anyway, some admittedly cherry-picked (but still somewhat telling) numbers:
A.J. Burnett's age on opening day 2009: 32
Brad Penny's age on opening day 2009: 30
Burnett's career adjusted ERA: 111
Penny's career adjusted ERA: 105
Burnett's top three single-season adjusted ERAs: 122, 119, 115 (twice).
Penny's top three single-season adjusted ERAs: 151, 130, 115.
Burnett's contract status:Signed a five-year, $82.5 million deal with the Yankees.
Penny's contract status: Agreed to one-year, $5 million deal (plus incentives) with the Red Sox.
Conclusion: If the shoulder is healthy -- and by most accounts, it is -- this is a tremendous low-risk, high-reward signing by the Sox. I know, in wake of the Teixeira bummer, we wanted a bigger name, something sexier. But this is shrewd, and I appreciate the Red Sox aren't doing something emotional and stupid in the aftermath of losing their coveted prize to their rival.
ABOUT TOUCHING ALL THE BASESIrreverence and insight from Chad Finn, a Globe/Boston.com sports writer and lifelong and incurable sports nut. Yes, he realizes how lucky he is. You can e-mail him at chadfinn4@yahoo.com.
browse this blog
by categoryTHE BEST OF TATB
- Vote for Pedro
- The best day ever
- 'David Ortiz has done it again!'
- Better man
- End of the idiots
- U gut male
- Questions we'd have asked the Texas Con Man
- Anniversary of an Angel
- The Air Coryell Chargers
- The top 10 Maine Guides
- The 1985 L.A. Clippers
- The day Yankees fans discovered TATB
- 'Without a doubt, I'll be part of the Celtics' tradition'
- The empire strikes out
- Shortstops: The boy band
- For Greenie, and Brian Denman, too
- The Big Ticket comes to Boston
- Do not bat this man second
- TATB Live: World Series, Game 4
- Josh Beckett, and that time I was right about everything
- Eau de Intangibles
- The loneliest number
- Sleep through the static
- Shining moments
- This place is meant for me
- I don't like the drugs but the drugs like me
- Red Sox All-Time Dirtbag Team
- Live from Ft. Myers
- Quiz me
- Turn, turn, turn
- Happy trails, No. 11
- Two great seasons
- Fireworks on Cloud 10
- The enemies list
- Ultimate Patriots Quiz, Part 1
- Ultimate Patriots Quiz, Part 2
- Guess that '70s Ballplayer, Part 1
- Guess that '70s Ballplayer, Part 2
- Guess that '70s Ballplayer, Part 3
- Guess that '70s Ballplayer, Part 4
- Reeling in the years
- Daddy's girl
- It was the best of times . . . "
- As Teixeira turns
- Dave Bourque
- The 20 most important Red Sox
- Tito's parting thoughts
- About last night
- A brief tribute to ancient pitchers
- Manny moments
- Pied Papi
- Superiority complex
- Seventeen so sweet
- Lefthanded compliment
- I'm a believer
R.I.P., 'OT'
MORE WRITING FROM CHAD
- Where have you gone, Tom Newell?
- Our favorite obscurities
- Everything I know about baseball I learned from Strat-O-Matic
- Lyman Bostock: Fallen Angel
- America's Team
- Roger the Dodger
- Thanks, mom
- The Pitino Dynasty
- Aim blame at Little
- Why the Patriots will beat the Rams
- Patriots 20, Rams 17
- The case against Lawyer Milloy
- Remembering Reggie Lewis
- Extraordinary Joe Johnson
- A very Brady sequel?
- Brady's the QB now - and in the future
- Curtis Martin: The one who got away
- Sweet, embraceable you
- James gives Sox strength in numbers
- These sports books have the write stuff
links
THE FUNDAMENTALS
- Barstool Sports
- Baseball Analysts
- Baseball Cube
- Boston Dirt Dogs
- Boston Sports Media
- Dave D'Onofrio
- Jenna Fischer
- Joe Posnanski
- Ken Levine
- Maine Headlines
- Maple Street Press
- Office Tally
- Seamheads
- Sons of Sam Horn
- Sports Pickle
- Surviving Grady
- The Big Lead
- SI Vault
- Cardboard Gods
ROLE PLAYERS
CHICKS DIG BLOGS
- Baseball Card Blog
- Baseball Desert
- Basegirl
- Bloop Single
- Boston Red Thoughts
- The Boston Score
- Bronx Banter
- Can't Stop The Bleeding
- Card Junkies
- Celtics Blog
- Central Maine Sports Blog
- The College Baseball Blog
- Cursed and First
- Empyreal Environs
- El Guapo's Ghost
- Fenway Fanatics
- Fenway Nation
- Firebrand of the A.L.
- For Love of the Sox
- Hardball Heaven
- The House That Dewey Built
- The Joy of Sox
- Over The Monster
- Papel-blog
- Red Socks Diaries
- Roto Authority
- Singapore Sox Fan
- Small White Ball
- Sox and Pinstripes
- Sox1Fan
- Sports Couch Potato
- Sportsthodoxy
- Tossing Batting Practice
- TLBR
- Yanks Fan vs. Sox Fan
THE OMBUDSMAN








