Dr. Karen Munkacy: Compassionate choice is for ‘safe and legal access’ to marijuana
I am a physician with 30 years’ experience, board certified in anesthesiology, fellowship trained in pain management and a breast cancer survivor. I know the importance of yearly mammograms, so when I was informed I had breast cancer in 2004, it came as a shock to me. I had my mammogram the year before and in just one year cancer had invaded my body. I was diagnosed with stage IIIB breast cancer.
When I was diagnosed my daughter was 17 and my son was 2 years old. To treat the disease, I was given the most aggressive chemotherapy regimen available for advanced breast cancer. This was extremely difficult with a toddler and a teenager. My husband and I had to move in with my in-laws during the course of my treatment. For four months, I laid in bed at their house suffering from nausea that was a thousand times worse than any flu, literally feeling like I was going to vomit hundreds of times a day. Taking a Marinol pill -- synthetic tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, available by prescription -- when I was that nauseous didn’t make sense. I didn’t want to take a pill that could be vomited as soon as it was swallowed.
Living through chemotherapy was absolute hell. But the worst part was the time I missed with my children. I did not have the strength to read my son bedtime stories, listen to him laugh and learn new words every day. At that time, he loved to be chased around, gaining confidence with every step he took. While my family was able to play with him, I laid helplessly in bed for days on end. I also missed many milestones of my daughter’s senior year of high school – another thing neither of us will get back. After chemotherapy I went through a double mastectomy with reconstruction and 28 radiation treatments. I decided there had to be a better way for patients to endure cancer treatments.
Throughout my career, patients had told me that medical marijuana provided a significant amount of relief for them. As a physician, I was skeptical. It was not until I did my own research on the subject after my struggle with cancer that I discovered medical marijuana provides unique benefits not just for cancer patients, but also for those suffering with HIV/AIDS, multiple sclerosis, paraplegia, Lou Gehrig’s disease, neuropathic pain, chronic vomiting syndrome, allodynia, ulcerative colitis, as well as many other debilitating conditions, and it is one of the safest medicines any patient can take.
Since my battle with cancer, I have studied the issue extensively and met with dozens of patients suffering from debilitating conditions who are unnecessarily being forced on to medications with dangerous side effects. Carbamazapine, for instance, is prescribed to prevent epileptic seizures, but can cause heart failure or fatal skin disease. Tysabri, prescribed for patients with multiple sclerosis, increases the risk of a fatal brain disease. Baclofen is primarily used for the treatment of spastic movement disorders, especially in instances of spinal cord injury, cerebral palsy, and multiple sclerosis, but withdrawal from Baclofen can cause death, if not treated appropriately. Medical marijuana can help address each of these afflictions without the dangerous side effects.
As a doctor I am confident in the science behind medical marijuana. More than 6,500 reports and journal articles around the world have been published about the medical value of marijuana to patients. Many of them can be found in an online database maintained by the International Association for Cannabinoid Medicines.
But I am a mother first. I would not be supporting this initiative if I thought it would have a negative impact on my children. I have talked extensively to my now 10-year-old and 25-year-old about the difference between medicine like marijuana that can help people and other prescribed medicine and drugs for recreational use. They fully recognize and respect the difference.
But the fact that there is such stringent state regulation in the Question 3 initiative is also so important to me. The proposed Massachusetts law is based on the best practices and lessons learned from the 17 other states that dispense medical marijuana. It requires that doctors writing recommendations have a bona fide relationship with their patients and that the state verifies all recommendations. It strictly limits the number of treatment centers to 35 nonprofit centers licensed and regulated by the state.
This initiative will be the safest medical marijuana law in the country. It creates a new felony for anyone who defrauds the medical marijuana system with a penalty of up to five years in prison for distribution. A person who now faces a mere civil fine for possession of less than an ounce of marijuana could be facing a criminal conviction and a jail sentence if they defraud the medical marijuana system. This approach provides greater regulation and oversight than some other states that have not set a limit on treatment centers or the requirements to qualify as a patient for medical marijuana.
Over 1,200 licensed doctors in Massachusetts have signed a statement in support of safe access to medical marijuana for patients with a doctor’s recommendation. The Massachusetts Nurses Association, AIDS Action Committee, Leukemia Lymphoma Society, New England Coalition of Cancer Survivorship, AIDS Foundation of Western Massachusetts, and Chronic Fatigue and Immune Deficiency Foundation have voiced support for safe access. Seventeen states, including our neighbors Vermont, Maine, Rhode Island and Connecticut and the District of Columbia, as well as Canada, the Netherlands, Israel, and Germany offer patients suffering from chronic and debilitating illnesses the ability to use medical marijuana.
I believe that when voters review the facts, they will have compassion for patients who are suffering from debilitating conditions. Decisions about patient care should be made by doctors and patients not by politicians or law enforcement. I believe that had I used medical marijuana during my treatments I would have had a much better quality of life. However, I refused to bring an illegal substance into my in-laws home.
As a doctor, I am advocating for safe and legal access to medical marijuana for patients with debilitating conditions because patients should not be denied an effective and safe treatment. As a doctor, cancer patient in remission, wife, and mother I am asking voters to have compassion for anyone who can be helped by medical marijuana.Dr. Karen Munkacy is a physician certified in anesthesiology and pain medicine now focused on public health initiatives. She is a board member at the Peter Rothschild Foundation in California. Massachusetts voters on Tuesday will consider become the 18th state to legalize marijuana use and distribution for medical use. This is one of two guest posts from physicians sharing their view on the proposal. Also see Dr. James Broadhurst’s take and read more about the debate over marijuana as medicine.
About white coat notes
|White Coat Notes covers the latest from the health care industry, hospitals, doctors offices, labs, insurers, and the corridors of government. Chelsea Conaboy previously covered health care for The Philadelphia Inquirer. Write her at firstname.lastname@example.org. Follow her on Twitter: @cconaboy.|
Gideon Gil, Health and Science Editor
Elizabeth Comeau, Senior Health Producer