WASHINGTON – The U.S. economy could be heading for a recession in the next year, according to growing warnings from banks and economists, as a sudden bout of economic pessimism hammers financial markets that had been counting on sustained economic momentum.
Although major swaths of the economy — including the job market and consumer spending — remain robust, there are mounting worries that rising borrowing costs for consumers and businesses, after years of near-zero interest rates, could cause a sudden retrenchment. The Federal Reserve has raised interest rates by 0.75 percentage points so far this year, while officials are signaling more aggressive hikes could be necessary to cool the economy. Continued uncertainty from the coronavirus pandemic and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine are adding to the uneasiness.
“Recession risks are high — uncomfortably high — and rising,” said Mark Zandi, chief economist at Moody’s Analytics. “For the economy to navigate through without suffering a downturn, we need some very deft policymaking from the Fed and a bit of luck.”
This week alone, former Goldman Sachs chief executive Lloyd Blankfein warned of a “very, very high risk” of recession; Wells Fargo CEO Charlie Scharf said there was “no question” that the U.S. economy is heading toward a downturn; and former Federal Reserve chair Ben Bernanke cautioned that the country could be poised for “stagflation” — a slowing economy combined with high inflation.
Those concerns come amid new smatterings of data that point to economic cooling, particularly in interest rate sensitive sectors that are already feeling the brunt of the Fed’s promise to keep tightening monetary conditions. New home construction slowed in April. Mortgage demand continues to decline.
Some of the country’s largest and most influential retailers reported disappointing sales and profits this week due to higher costs and overstocked inventory issues, engineered to avoid supply chain disruptions, setting off a stock market meltdown. Walmart’s stock plunged more than 11% on Tuesday, its worst one-day loss in 35 years. On Wednesday, Target’s shares tumbled 26%, following a stunning 52% drop in quarterly profits, which executives attributed in part to cooling demand for big-ticket items like TVs, kitchen appliances and outdoor furniture.
“While we anticipated a post-stimulus slowdown in these categories . . . we didn’t anticipate the magnitude of that shift,” Brian Cornell, Target’s chief executive, said in a Wednesday earnings call. “When we talk to our guests, they often express their concerns about a host of rapidly changing conditions, ranging from geopolitics to the high and persistent inflation they’ve been experiencing.”
Goldman Sachs this week revised down its forecast for second-quarter U.S. economic growth, to 2.5%, citing higher prices and continued supply chain disruptions. That follows an unexpected contraction in the first three months of 2022, when the economy shrank 1.4%, mostly because of a trade imbalance and a drop in inventory purchases.
International turmoil, including a risk of recession in Europe and China, is dimming the outlook for the U.S. economy. And a strengthening U.S. dollar — as rate hikes make dollar investments more attractive — could dampen exports, raising the chances of a technical recession in which the economy contracts for two quarters in a row.
That fear of a souring economy as well as shifts in consumer pandemic spending habits have led a number of highflying tech darlings including Netflix and Peloton to announce layoffs in recent weeks. Twitter and Meta have paused hiring plans, while Amazon executives recently said the company was “overstaffed” after months of brisk hiring.
Meanwhile, inflation, which remains near 40-year highs, has become a central challenge for both the economy and the Biden administration. Higher prices for basics like food, energy and housing are straining Americans’ budgets and clouding their view of the economy. Gas prices soared to yet another all-time high this week, with average prices hitting $4.57 per gallon nationwide. A closely watched consumer sentiment index by the University of Michigan shows that Americans’ views of their current finances and future expectations have fallen sharply in the past year.
Despite that gloomy outlook, Americans continue to spend heartily. Sales of clothing, cars and furniture all ticked up in April, contributing to a 0.9% increase in overall retail sales from a month earlier, according to Commerce Department data released this week.
“Near term, the U.S. economy is holding up rather well despite the trouble abroad and the high prices at the checkout stand,” said Beth Ann Bovino, chief U.S. economist for S&P Global, who says there’s a 35% risk of recession in the next year. “People are spending, businesses are still trying to hire. But there are certainly challenges ahead. The Fed’s actions will slow the economy, but the question is whether they could also topple the applecart.”
Even if the United States staves off a recession in the short-term, some economists say the sheer pace of inflation, with prices up 8.3% in the past year, and the persistent supply and demand imbalances caused by the pandemic, and the policy responses to it, could snowball into an even more severe crisis down the line.
“Consumers are spending like crazy, businesses are going to need to rebuild their inventories, and a lot of workers are still flowing back into the labor market,” said Jason Furman, an economics professor at Harvard University who served as an adviser during the Obama administration. “But all of this makes me worry about one or two or three years from now — because it might mean the Fed needs to raise rates even more, and it might mean you create an even bigger recession later.”
Zandi, of Moody’s, said skyrocketing gas and commodity prices from pandemic-related supply chain snarls and the Ukraine war have added to the specter of an economic downturn. He now puts the odds of a U.S. recession in the next 24 months at about 50%.
“We’re traveling very close to the edge,” he said. “The housing market is the next thing that’s going to roll over; the question is just how hard.”
New home construction fell in April, led by a slowdown in single-family homes. Building permits, which offer a glimpse into future construction, also declined, according to data released this week by the Census Bureau and the Department of Housing and Urban Development.
“Home builder sentiment fell to the lowest level in two years in May,” Yelena Maleyev, an economist for Grant Thornton, said in an analyst note. “Builders are seeing less foot traffic and expect sales to be softer as we enter the busy home-buying season.”
That softening is already rippling through the economy. Major mortgage lenders across the country, including Wells Fargo and Better.com, have laid off thousands in recent weeks as a result of dwindling demand for home loans and refinancing.
In Alexandria, Va., mortgage lender Kevin Retcher said there is a discernible skittishness among potential home buyers. Refinances began tumbling late last year, around the time the Fed began signaling upcoming rate hikes. In the months since, a combination of rising mortgage rates — now at 5.3% for a fixed-rate 30-year mortgage, nearly double early 2021 levels — and sky-high home prices have begun deterring buyers, he said. At least three clients have gotten “cold feet” and pulled out of ratified contracts in the last two weeks, he added.
“There is an extreme sense of nervousness out there,” said Retcher, president of First Meridian Mortgage. “It’s rare to have people win contracts and then back out, but that’s what’s been happening.”
Other types of small businesses say they’re seeing a pullback in consumer demand, too, as customers grapple with rising costs. Aaron Mulherin, who owns a glass repair company in Marion, Iowa, said that while homeowners are continuing to spring for necessities like fixing broken windows, they’re starting to think twice about spending on luxuries like custom showers.
“Average, middle-class consumers are starting to hesitate,” Mulherin said. “Everything is getting more expensive, so they’re getting an estimate, then putting it off.”