Why the Sox didn’t announce Drew, Lugo

LAKE BUENA VISTA, Fla. — You may wonder why the Sox left it for J.D. Drew’s agent, Scott Boras, to announce they’d struck a deal with the free-agent right fielder, and why they also had nothing to say publicly about striking a deal with free-agent shortstop Julio Lugo. Let me tell you about Xavier Hernandez.

Xavier Hernandez was a relief pitcher and free agent in the winter of 1998. The Orioles announced that they’d signed him to a contract, but made no mention that his signing was contingent on Hernandez passing a physical.

Hernandez flunked his physical — tests showed a partial tear of his rotator cuff — and the Orioles tried to void the deal. Hernandez and his agent filed an appeal, arguing that the Orioles’ public announcement that he had been signed was the equivalent of a signing itself. An arbitrator agreed, and Hernandez was awarded $1.75 million, even though he never threw a pitch for Baltimore.


Ever since, teams have been gun-shy about announcing a deal pending a physical. Some teams are more gun-shy than others, like the current Sox regime, but they’re acting on the advice of MLB lawyers.

Loading Comments...

Ski season updates, free from The Boston Globe.
Get the Globe's free newsletter, It's All Downhill, for the latest from the slopes.
Thanks for signing up!