Extra Bases

Looking deeper at Beltre

A reader just e-mailed to make a case for Adrian Beltre. And he makes a good one.

His contention is that Beltre’s 2009 season can’t be properly evaluated because of his bad left shoulder. From 2006-08, Beltre hit .287 with an .842 OPS on the road.It stands to reason he would be better at Fenway than he was at Safeco Field, a poor park for righthanded hitters.

Finally, the reader passed along this interesting blog post from Andy Baggarly of the San Jose Mercury News. Baggarly checked out some lofty claims made by Scott Boras and found that, in fact, Safeco Field certainly was no friend to Beltre.


But two questions remain:

1. Has Beltre recovered sufficiently from the surgery he had in June? He was at .276/.329/.388 after the surgery, but 20 of the 38 games he played were at Safeco. It’s all well and good to look at what he did from 2006-09 but in 2009 the bone spurs he thought he had removed came back.

2. Is Beltre willing to sign a contract agreeable to the Red Sox? Boras was reportedly seeking three years and $39 million. It’s hard to see the Sox suddenly adding $13 million to their payroll.

UPDATE, 3:27 p.m.: I amended the original post. The reader was talking about Beltre’s road splits. I took out the Jason Bay comparisons as it didn’t seem relevant to the overall point that Beltre could be a helpful player.

Jump To Comments


This discussion has ended. Please join elsewhere on Boston.com