How 15 NFL experts graded the Patriots’ 2020 draft class

"Bill Belichick's first post-Brady group felt solid."

Kyle Dugger
Former Lenoir-Rhyne defensive back Kyle Dugger speaks during a press conference. AJ Mast/AP Photo

The 2020 NFL Draft has come and gone, leaving the start of in-person offseason workoutspostponed due to COVID-19 – as the next thing to look forward to on the football calendar.

Related Links

Over the weekend, the Patriots drafted 10 players, in the form of a safety, two edge defenders, two tight ends, a kicker, a guard, an offensive tackle, a linebacker, and a center. Here’s what NFL experts had to say how the newest additions to New England will fit into the needs of a Tom Brady-less Patriots team.

Grading the draft class

Vinnie Iyer, Sporting News: B+

“The Patriots always start with a high floor because of Bill Belichick’s ability to know when to stockpile picks. Defensively, they loaded up on ideal versatile players […] One can’t ignore, however, the lack of a quarterback to compete with Jarrett Stidham.”


Chad Reuter, B

“Bill Belichick and his dog understood the team’s needs on the edge, in the secondary and at tight end. Not everyone agreed with the value of the tight ends selected, but their versatility and athleticism may ultimately shine through.”

Pro Football Focus: B

“In playing for Lenoir-Rhyne and going up against lower-level competition, Kyle Dugger is a huge unknown, as he dominated just because of his unreal athleticism as opposed to reading in coverage.”

Dan Kadar, SBNation: B

“Going into the draft, I thought this would be one where Bill Belichick leaned into defense and his comfort zone, and that’s what happened.”


Nate Davis, USA Today: B

“It’s been some time since they produced a collective slam dunk and have been especially dreadful in Round 2 for nearly a decade. That said…Bill Belichick’s first post-Brady group felt solid.” 

Mark Maske, The Washington Post: B-

“It was all very Belichick-like, but this approach puts a tremendous amount of trust in second-year QB Jarrett Stidham.”

Pete Prisco, CBS Sports: C+

“The Pats appear to be in rebuilding mode in a big way.” 

Luke Easterling, Draft Wire: C+

“Things started strong for the Patriots after they traded out of the first round, but they faded down the stretch.” 


Mel Kiper, ESPN: C+

“My biggest issue with this class is no quarterback. The Patriots passed on Jalen Hurts, Jacob Eason, and Jake Fromm throughout. I’m not sold that 2019 fourth-rounder Jarrett Stidham should be the unquestioned starter.” 

Ryan Dunleavy, New York Post: C+

“Strange. No quarterback is even stranger.”

Andy Benoit, Sports Illustrated: C+

“As usual, most of New England’s picks were spent with the future in mind.”

Hayden Winks, Rotoworld: C

“New England had a ton of draft picks coming into the draft and predictably moved all over the board (5 trades), but the guys Bill Belichick selected have very questionable profiles.” 


Jake Rill, Bleacher Report: C

Taking a closer look

Kyle Dugger, S

Chris Trapasso, CBS Sports: A

Ian Higgins, B

“[Devin] McCourty is a quality coverage safety and [Patrick] Chung is a gritty box safety, but Dugger is a player who can fill either role and excel with his playmaking ability.”

Andy Benoit, Sports Illustrated: C

“This one is a bit of a head-scratcher for the simple reason that the Patriots entered this draft with four quality safeties already…he doesn’t feel a need, but there is no question he fits the scheme.” 

Josh Uche.


Josh Uche, OLB

Trapasso: A

Higgins: B

“Both Kyle Van Noy and Jamie Collins did their best work in New England’s defensive system with unique outside linebackers, and Uche comes in ready to play day one.”

Benoit: C+

“New England has a sound front seven given the context of their scheme, but it could stand to have more athleticism on the edges.”

Anfernee Jennings, LB

Higgins: A

“Similarly to Josh Uche, Jennings is a versatile outside linebacker who will be able to operate on the edge in New England’s hybrid defense.”

Benoit: B

“You can afford to draft for depth when you have over a dozen picks. This particular pick is an excellent scheme fit.”


Trapasso: C+

Devin Asiasi.

Devin Asiasi, TE 

Benoit: B+

“Though not quite possessing ideal length, Asiasi intrigues as a route runner, particularly down the seams and on play-action.”

Higgins: B

“Even without elite size for the position, Asiasi plays big and is able to do some of the same things that make any tight end elite.” 

Trapasso: B

Dalton Keene, TE

Benoit: B

Trapasso: C+

Higgins: D

“I understand the idea here, but why would the New England Patriots take back-to-back tight ends and made neither of them Albert Okwuegbunam or Adam Trautman?”

Justin Rohrwasser, PK

Higgins: B+

“Even if overshadowed by kickers from larger schools, he has the statistics and situational performance to justify being the first special teamer off of the board.”

Trapasso: F

Michael Onwenu, G

Trapasso: B+

Higgins: C

“New England has had rumors swirling around the trade of guard Joe Thuney due to cap restrictions, and Onwenu could be a good replacement to fill a specific role and not cost much in terms of cap space or draft capital.”

Justin Herron Wake Forest Patriots

Justin Herron.

Justin Herron, OT

Trapasso: C+

Higgins: C

“With a future need at tackle, Belichick has put a succession plan in place for longtime Patriot Marcus Cannon.”

Cassh Maluia, LB

Higgins: B

“Maluia does not have the same physical frame or gifts of his new teammates but can fill the role of sub linebacker and produce on coverage.” 

Trapasso: D

Dustin Woodard, C

Higgins: C

“If Woodard can manage to impress the coaching staff throughout his rookie season, Belichick and company will cut [David] Andrews loose [in 2021] and play the seventh-round draft pick with a cheap contract that fits into their system.”

Trapasso: C-

Jump To Comments


This discussion has ended. Please join elsewhere on