Sports News

Ivy League moves to eliminate tackling at practices

Harvard defensive back Scott Peters tackles Yale wide receiver Christopher Williams-Lopez during an NCAA college football game. AP

Ivy League football coaches have decided to take the extraordinary step of eliminating all full-contact hitting from practices during the regular season, the most aggressive measure yet to combat growing concerns about brain trauma and other injuries in the sport.

The move could influence how other football programs, from the youth level to the professionals, try to mitigate the physical toll of football, which has been played on Ivy League campuses since the 19th century.

The eight Ivy League coaches unanimously approved the measure last week. Their decision is expected to be adopted formally once it is affirmed by the league’s athletic directors, policy committee and university presidents. The new rule would be in addition to the Ivy League’s existing limits on the amount of full contact in practice during the spring and preseason, which are among the most stringent in collegiate football.

Research has shown that limiting the amount of full-contact practices can reduce the number of concussions. In the NFL, for instance, concussions during practices in the preseason and regular season have declined since 2012, the year after limits on the number of full-contact practices were put in place. (Concussions overall rose last year, however.)

The research on limiting full contact in practice “all shows that you not only have fewer subconcussive hits, but also concussions,’’ said Dr. Robert Cantu, co-director of the Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy at the Boston University School of Medicine. “It’s not rocket science.’’

The Ivy League’s new rule was inspired by one of its members, Dartmouth, where full-contact practices throughout the year were eliminated by coach Buddy Teevens starting in 2010 to reduce injuries, including concussions, that kept players out of games and wore them down over the course of a season.


At first, some players and coaches worried that they would lose their competitive fire, Teevens said. Instead of hitting other players in practice, Dartmouth players hit pads and tackling dummies, including a specially designed “mobile virtual player’’ that moves across the field the way a player would.

“At this stage in their careers, these guys know how to hit and take a hit,’’ Teevens said in a phone interview. “People look at it and say we’re nuts. But it’s kept my guys healthy.’’

The Ivy League — which consists of Brown, Columbia, Cornell, Dartmouth, Harvard, Pennsylvania, Princeton and Yale — has been one of the most aggressive college conferences in addressing the risks associated with the collisions that are endemic to the game. In 2011, the league sharply reduced the number of full-contact practices teams could hold, going beyond the rules set by the NCAA at the time.

The league also reviewed the rules governing men’s and women’s hockey, lacrosse and soccer to determine if there were ways to reduce hits to the head and concussions in those sports.

Leagues from Pop Warner to the NFL, sometimes reluctantly, have also restricted the amount of contact in practices, when many concussions and other injuries occur. Coaches across the country have eliminated the Oklahoma Drill and other techniques that require that players butt heads.

Dozens of states, which govern public school athletic programs, reduced practice-field contact, something advocated by Practice Like Pros, a group that promotes less contact in practices.

Terry O’Neil, who runs the group, said that only 3 percent of concussions sustained in the NFL occur on the practice field; in high school, the rate is 60 percent to 75 percent.


Groups like the Ivy League, which have limited full contact in practices, “have been forced to improvise and innovate without full contact to the point where they are so comfortable with it, they vote to eliminate full contact completely,’’ O’Neil said.

Some youth leagues have gone even further to reduce the risk of head trauma. The Boys & Girls Club in Marshall, Texas, for instance, shuttered its tackle football program and focuses more on flag football.

The NFL now allows 14 full-contact practices during the 18-week regular season, although some teams never reach that limit.

The NCAA guidelines are more permissive. Teams that hold two-a-day practices can have full contact in one of them. Full-contact practices are allowed up to four times in a week, and a maximum of 12 times during the preseason. During the season, teams can hold full-contact practices no more than twice a week.

Teevens said that his restrictions on full contact in practice helped reduce the number of concussions his team sustained to just a handful each season from about 20 a year before full-contact practices were eliminated. The number of neck, back and shoulder injuries also declined noticeably, he said.

“You’d have more stuff occur because we were banging each other,’’ he said.

Teevens said that contrary to some fears, his players have become better tacklers. Players still tackle from 500 to 800 times a year, but instead of launching themselves at other players in practice, they focus on how they tackle to avoid head collisions. The number of missed tackles in games has fallen by more than half, he said.


“It hasn’t hurt our level of play,’’ he said. “It’s actually made us a better team.’’

Jump To Comments


This discussion has ended. Please join elsewhere on